
Grayson Hotel
Best for rooftop cocktails, multiple on-site dining outlets, and a lively, bar-forward Midtown stay.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Grayson Hotel is a contemporary 4-star boutique hotel (opened 2022) with multiple bars and rooftop views near Bryant Park; read this if you want a newer, social Midtown option. The St. Regis New York is a historic 5-star grand-luxury hotel on Fifth Avenue with traditional butler service; read this if you prefer classic Fifth Avenue prestige and large suites.
Updated · about 1.2 km apart

Best for rooftop cocktails, multiple on-site dining outlets, and a lively, bar-forward Midtown stay.

Best for traditional Fifth Avenue luxury, framed suites with Butler Service, and a long-standing hotel address for formal events.
When Grayson Hotel wins: choose Grayson if you want a newer property with several distinct dining/drink venues (including a rooftop mezcaleria), modern fitness facilities, and a more casual, social vibe steps from Bryant Park.
When The St. Regis New York wins: choose The St. Regis for classic, formal luxury, a wide selection of suite types with Butler Service included in many room listings, central Fifth Avenue location near Rockefeller Center and Museum of Modern Art, and larger meeting/banquet capacity.
Bottom line: both deliver polished Manhattan luxury; pick Grayson for contemporary, bar-driven Midtown energy and easy access to Bryant Park, or pick The St. Regis for historic Fifth Avenue prestige and traditional suite service.
| Category | Grayson Hotel | The St. Regis New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Contemporary boutique luxury with an emphasis on bars and social dining | Historic grand-luxury with formal service and Butler Service in many room types |
| Location | Midtown near Bryant Park (30 West 39th St) | Fifth Avenue, near Rockefeller Center and MoMA (Two East 55th St) |
| Size (rooms / floors) | 296 guestrooms across 28 floors | 238 guestrooms (room count published in supplier listing) |
| Opened / age | Opened 2022 (new-build) | Long-established historic hotel (well-known long history; modern opening year not published in supplied listing) |
| Pools | No on-site swimming pool | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Harta (New American), Bar Harta (wine terrace), Bar Cima (rooftop mezcaleria), Tacalle (seasonal taco garden) | 2 restaurants and 1 bar/lounge listed; room service available (limited hours) |
| Spa / wellness | No on-site spa; partner spa experiences available off-site; 24-hour GRIT fitness center on site | Hair salon and 24-hour fitness facilities listed; spa details not published |
| Known for | Rooftop cocktails and multiple on-site dining venues near Bryant Park | Fifth Avenue grandeur and Butler Service included in many room types |
| Meetings & events | Helix meeting room (about 700 sq ft) and several on-site private event venues (including rooftop and courtyard options) | 13 meeting rooms and about 3,944 sq ft (366 m²) of conference space |
| Accessibility & family policy | Welcomes families; minimum check-in age 21; pet-friendly with fees | |
Grayson sits on West 39th Street, a block from Bryant Park and close to the New York Public Library and Times Square.
Choose Grayson for immediate access to Bryant Park and a lively Midtown neighborhood.
The St. Regis New York sits on Fifth Avenue, a few blocks from Rockefeller Center and major Midtown museums.
Choose The St. Regis for a classic Fifth Avenue address and proximity to Rockefeller Center and museum row.
Grayson has nearly 300 modern guestrooms and a few interconnected suites with private balconies on the fourth floor.
Grayson delivers contemporary guestrooms with some rare Midtown outdoor-suite options.
The St. Regis lists many room types including numerous Butler Service–included categories and a range of 1‑bedroom suites.
The St. Regis is the choice for travelers who prioritize Butler Service and a wide selection of formal suite layouts.
Grayson's food and drink offer varied, on-site options from a brasserie to a rooftop mezcal bar and a seasonal taco garden.
Grayson is better if you want multiple on-property dining/drink experiences and rooftop views.
The St. Regis offers two restaurants and a bar/lounge with room service available during limited hours.
The St. Regis suits travelers who prefer formal dining and traditional hotel food service.
Grayson emphasizes rooftop and social bar experiences as signature parts of the property.
Grayson’s rooftop and bars are the hotel's chief distinguishing features.
The St. Regis’s signature assets are its Butler Service room categories and extensive event/banquet facilities.
St. Regis’s traditional service model and event facilities are the main draw for formal stays and events.
Grayson provides a 24-hour fitness center and nightlife via its bars; it does not operate an on-site spa or pool.
Pick Grayson if a modern 24-hour gym plus active bars and rooftop nightlife matter to you.
The St. Regis lists 24-hour fitness and salon services; published spa and pool details are not provided in the supplier listing.
St. Regis offers classic hotel wellness features; specific spa and pool details are not published in the supplied listing.

Grayson — Bar Cima and rooftop seating provide direct skyline views and a large agave spirits selection.

The St. Regis New York — many room types explicitly include Butler Service and the property is known for its formal service.

Grayson — opened 2022, welcomes families with a family stay kit and multiple casual dining options.

The St. Regis New York — 13 meeting rooms and ~3,944 sq ft of conference/banquet space support larger formal events.
Grayson — it has Bar Cima, a rooftop mezcaleria with seasonal outdoor seating and skyline views.
The St. Regis New York — several published room types explicitly include Butler Service.
Grayson does not have an on-site pool; published pool details for The St. Regis New York are not provided in the supplied listing.
Yes — both welcome families. Both properties require a registered guest age of 21 to check in.
Explore how Grayson Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·