
Grayson Hotel
Best for guests who want rooftop cocktails (Bar Cima), multiple on-site dining venues and easy access to Bryant Park and Midtown theaters.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Grayson Hotel is a contemporary 4-star boutique in Midtown Manhattan (Bryant Park) with rooftop mezcal, family-friendly services and 296 rooms. The New York EDITION is a 5-star luxury lifestyle hotel by Madison Square Park with refined dining (The Clocktower) and about 271 rooms — read this if you’re choosing between a Bryant Park boutique with rooftop nightlife and a Madison Square Park–side EDITION experience.
Updated · about 1.5 km apart

Best for guests who want rooftop cocktails (Bar Cima), multiple on-site dining venues and easy access to Bryant Park and Midtown theaters.

Best for travelers seeking a classic EDITION experience close to Madison Square Park, Flatiron and a signature hotel restaurant (The Clocktower).
When Grayson Hotel wins: choose Grayson if you want a newer boutique in Midtown with a busy rooftop mezcal bar (Bar Cima), several on-site casual and seasonal dining options (Tacalle taco garden, Bar Harta, Harta) and family-friendly amenities.
When The New York EDITION wins: pick The New York EDITION if you prefer an established 5-star EDITION property near Madison Square Park and Flatiron with a noted signature restaurant and on-site spa services.
Bottom line: both hotels offer design-forward, lifestyle stays in Manhattan — Grayson is a newer Midtown boutique with a strong rooftop/drinks program and family-friendly focus; The New York EDITION is a slightly larger 5-star option for travelers prioritizing EDITION’s restaurant, bars and Madison Square Park location.
| Category | Grayson Hotel | The New York EDITION |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Contemporary Midtown boutique with seasonal outdoor venues and a rooftop mezcal bar. | Luxury lifestyle EDITION with refined restaurant and dual lounges; classic EDITION style. |
| Location | 30 West 39th Street — a block from Bryant Park and close to Fifth Avenue shopping. | 5 Madison Avenue — steps from Madison Square Park and Flatiron Building. |
| Size (rooms) | 296 guestrooms across 28 floors. | 271 air-conditioned rooms. |
| Check‑in / Check‑out | Check-in begins at 3:00 PM; check-out by 11:00 AM. | Check-in begins at 4:00 PM; check-out by 11:00 AM. |
| Pools | No on-site swimming pool. | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Harta (New American), Bar Harta (wine terrace), Bar Cima (rooftop mezcal), Tacalle (seasonal taco garden). | The Clocktower (hotel restaurant), 2 bars/lounges and 24‑hour room service. |
| Spa & wellness | No in-house spa; partner spa (Oasis Day Spa) available via booking; 24‑hour GRIT fitness center on site. | Spa services on site plus fitness facilities and 24‑hour front desk. |
| Known for | Rooftop mezcaleria (Bar Cima), Tacalle taco garden and Bryant Park access. | Madison Square Park location, The Clocktower restaurant and EDITION branding. |
| Accessibility & meetings | Helix meeting room (boardroom), event venues and hybrid meeting capabilities; luggage storage and porter services. | 2100 sq ft conference space, 5 meeting rooms, wheelchair-accessible features and concierge services. |
| Pet policy | Pets welcome (dogs & cats) for a fee; on-site off-leash area and in-room bowls. | Pets can be arranged (surcharges apply; contact property). |
Grayson Hotel sits at 30 West 39th Street, one block from Bryant Park and close to Fifth Avenue shopping.
Choose Grayson for immediate Midtown/Bryant Park access and shopping/theater convenience.
The New York EDITION is at 5 Madison Avenue, steps from Madison Square Park and the Flatiron Building.
Pick The New York EDITION for a stay centered on Madison Square Park and Flatiron dining and shopping.
Grayson offers 296 guestrooms across 28 floors with a handful of named room types and interconnecting suites on the fourth floor.
Grayson emphasizes modern, boutique room amenities and a small number of interconnecting suites with balconies.
The New York EDITION has 271 air-conditioned rooms including Studio, Deluxe, Loft and named suites (Madison, Flatiron, Park, Penthouse).
The EDITION provides a broad set of room types and named suites for travelers seeking classic EDITION room categories and accessibility options.
Grayson’s dining spans a New American brasserie, a wine terrace, a rooftop mezcaleria and a seasonal taco garden.
Grayson is strong on varied on-site venues — casual to rooftop — all run by the same operator (Apicii).
The New York EDITION highlights The Clocktower restaurant plus two bars/lounges and 24-hour room service.
The EDITION centers on a signature dining experience and several lounges — suited to guests seeking refined in-house dining.
Grayson’s signature amenity is its rooftop Bar Cima and multiple seasonal outdoor dining spaces rather than a pool.
Grayson’s rooftop and outdoor venues are the primary social draw — not a pool.
The New York EDITION’s notable public amenities include The Clocktower dining, two bars and event/conference space.
The EDITION’s public strengths are its restaurant, lounges and event space; spa services are offered on site.
Grayson combines a 24-hour GRIT fitness center with off-site partner spa access and an active rooftop bar scene.
Grayson suits guests who want a strong fitness offering and an active rooftop/drinks scene rather than a full-service on-site spa.
The New York EDITION lists onsite spa services and fitness facilities alongside bar and lounge nightlife.
The EDITION provides a conventional hotel wellness offering with on-site spa treatments combined with lounge nightlife.

Grayson Hotel — Bar Cima is a dedicated rooftop mezcaleria with skyline views.

The New York EDITION — The Clocktower is the hotel’s notable restaurant and a focal point of the property.

Grayson Hotel — family stay kits, interconnecting suites (with private balconies on the 4th floor) and kid-friendly dining options.

The New York EDITION — listed 2100 sq ft of conference space and five meeting rooms for events.
Grayson Hotel — Bar Cima is a rooftop mezcaleria with seasonal outdoor seating and skyline views; The New York EDITION has lounges but Grayson is focused on rooftop cocktails.
The New York EDITION lists on-site spa services (massages and facials). Grayson does not operate an in-house spa; guests can book a partner spa experience at Oasis Day Spa.
No — both hotels welcome guests of all ages. Grayson explicitly provides family stay kits; the EDITION listing notes pet policies and accessibility but does not indicate an adults-only policy.
Grayson Hotel — it sits a block from Bryant Park. The New York EDITION is farther south near Madison Square Park (about 1.5 km between the two hotels).
Explore how Grayson Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·